Draft Model Legislation / Code of Practice
Purpose:
To establish an independent, mandatory, accessible, and consumer-focused National Motor Ombudsman to resolve disputes between consumers and automotive industry participants efficiently, transparently, and fairly.
Definitions:
Motor Vehicle Trader: Any business engaged in sale, lease, repair, servicing, or warranty provision for motor vehicles.
Consumer: Any person acquiring, leasing, or using a motor vehicle for personal or household purposes.
Dispute: Any disagreement or complaint arising from motor vehicle sale, lease, servicing, warranty, or associated finance.
Scope:
The Ombudsman shall cover:
-
New and used vehicle sales;
-
Vehicle servicing, repairs, and warranties;
-
Extended warranties, manufacturer guarantees, and aftermarket add-ons;
-
Vehicle finance and insurance products related to consumer purchases;
-
Misleading or deceptive conduct by motor traders;
-
Disputes arising from recalls or safety defects.
Mandatory Membership / Coverage:
-
All motor vehicle traders must register with the Ombudsman and comply with its Codes of Practice.
-
Non-members are prohibited from trading vehicles or offering services until registered.
-
Compliance includes adherence to dispute resolution decisions and reporting obligations.
Powers of the Ombudsman:
-
Investigation & Mediation: Investigate complaints, mediate between parties, and issue findings.
-
Binding Decisions: Final decisions are legally binding on traders, with limited judicial review.
-
Remedies: The Ombudsman may award repair, replacement, refund, compensation, and adjustment of finance/insurance contracts.
-
Enforcement: Authority to refer non-compliant traders to regulatory bodies, impose fines, and revoke membership.
Consumer Access & Protections:
-
Free Access: Consumers shall not pay fees to lodge complaints.
-
Timeliness: Complaints must be resolved within 90–120 days.
-
Support Services: Access to neutral technical inspections, translations, advocacy, and digital case tracking.
-
Transparency: Publish anonymized case summaries, compliance statistics, and annual reports audited independently.
Governance:
-
Independent Board: Consumer majority (≥50%), industry limited to advisory, Independent Chair appointed by neutral public body.
-
Reporting: Annual public report to Parliament and independent audit.
-
Conflict-of-Interest Rules: Board members/staff cannot hold financial or management interests in automotive businesses.
Funding Mechanisms:
-
Levy on industry turnover: Stable, ring-fenced, protects independence.
-
Flat annual accreditation fee: Simple, links participation to compliance.
-
Government grant/appropriation: Stable, requires independence safeguards.
-
Hybrid (industry levy + government grant): Diversified, reduces capture risk.
-
Consumer-funded (per-vehicle fee): Scales with usage, low industry influence.
-
Trust/endowment fund: Strong protection against interference. Best options: Hybrid funding with ring-fenced levy + government grant or independent trust/endowment.
Reporting & Accountability:
-
Quarterly and annual reports including complaints, outcomes, compliance, resolution times.
-
Independent audit of financials, decisions, and enforcement.
-
Transparent anonymized case database accessible to policymakers and consumer advocacy bodies.
Transitional & Implementation Rules:
-
12-month transition period for trader registration and compliance.
-
Any existing voluntary schemes may be absorbed.
-
Regulations to specify operational procedures, complaint intake, and technical inspections.
Summary of Key Features:
-
Mandatory coverage for all traders.
-
Legally binding decisions.
-
Independent governance with consumer majority.
-
Fast, free, accessible consumer pathway.
-
Neutral technical inspection and advocacy support.
-
Transparent reporting and auditing.
-
Stable, protected funding minimizing industry or political capture.